Politics as Instantiations from the Range of Human Nature

  • A range of human nature has always existed; moral panic derives from folks at one end of the spectrum noticing that folks exist at the other end;
  • David French on how Republicans have learned nothing from the midterm elections.
  • Paul Krugman about Republican ideology, and this past weekend;
  • How Republicans are flirting with the repeal of the 19th amendment, about allowing women to vote.
– – –

 

Thought for the day, triggered by one of the books I’m current reading. There have been any number of crises of religious panic throughout human history, with alarmists worried about ‘moral decay’. These are illusions. They occur when conservatives, black and white thinkers, notice that other people have more relaxed attitudes (able to perceive gray and even colors) and think they are flawed and are in need of redemption/correction. Into their own rigid worldview. The spectrum of moral behavior has always existed in human nature.

Again, we don’t expect Republicans/conservatives to learn anything.

NY Times, opinion by David French, yesterday: A Republican Party That’s Learned Nothing

The Republican Party has not learned its lesson.

Consider what’s happened since Nov. 3, when it faced the largest midterm electoral rebuke that any party has received since at least 1974.

So they double down.

Stephen Miller, Jim Jordan, legal threats against Democrats for conducting investigations, shielding Pete Hegseth, shielding Jensen Huang. All of which means they might well keep failing. Perhaps they won’t bounce back in two years. A passage later in the essay:

Ten years of Trump have so divorced the Republican Party from any sense of ethics — or any coherent ideology — that for many people, the conservatism of even the recent past feels liberal. It feels woke.

Appeals to human dignity? A reverence for basic human rights? Preservation of liberal democracy abroad? It all sounds so squishy. And besides, if we go down that path, won’t millions of (ugh) Democrats agree?

It’s always tempting to say, this has all happened before. There’s no escaping it. And yet, global humanity is far better off now than it was 100, or 1000 years ago. And it’s not because of conservatives (or religion).

\\\

Thus recently.

Paul Krugman, today: Republican Ideology Ruined Your Weekend, subtitled “Decades of underinvestment, then two years of DOGE vandalism and destruction, grounded American air travel”

He recounts the failure leading up to “Ground Stop Day,” which delayed his own trip by 24 hours. The failed router.

So far there is no specific reason to doubt this story, just the fact that Trump officials lie about everything.

As I jotted down earlier today: we know by now not to take anything this administration says at face value. And sure enough, they have been blaming Biden, and Buttigieg, as if they haven’t noticed these problems in the past two years they’ve been in power, and spent money on ballrooms and arches instead.

Further observations from Reich:

But why are the FAA’s systems so outdated? And I mean outdated: The agency is planning to phase out floppy disks by 2028.

The answer is that the FAA isn’t unusual. In the U.S., government at all levels — federal, state and local — runs on outdated software and hardware, with legacy systems basically held together with paper clips and rubber bands. During the Covid crisis, as states scrambled to provide temporarily enhanced unemployment benefits, we learned that many states were still administering benefits using systems running on COBOL, a programming language introduced in 1959.

This reliance on antiquated technology isn’t because government workers are stupid. It’s because for many decades they haven’t been given the resources to upgrade their equipment. America used to have a government that invested in the future. But ever since Ronald Reagan declared that “…government is not the solution to our problem; government is the problem”, critical government functions have been starved of funds for investment.

In ways we didn’t all notice at the time, Reagan was the core of the Republican rot in American society. (But he seemed so *nice*.) He appealed to the base of American anti-intellectualism.

\\\

More evidence of resurgent tribal morality.

NY Times, opinion by Ivana Greco (“a senior fellow at Capita, a nonpartisan think tank focused on family policy”), today: Conservatives Can’t Afford to Humor ‘Repeal the 19th’

That would be about the right of women to vote.

Should they work outside the home? Are they as smart as men? For years, those questions found audiences primarily in the extreme online world of the “manosphere,” where influencers get clicks by answering: “no.” Today, their formerly fringe ideas have escaped the dark recesses of social media and are gaining support in the real world, including (but not only) at elite religious and conservative colleges.

And,

Conservative think tanks, elected officials and the Republican Party itself have all struggled to offer a comprehensive response to the rise of this ideology, which I’ll call radical anti-feminism. Politicians have refused to acknowledge just how troubling these ideas are; some, such as Pete Hegseth, are elevating them. As a conservative myself, the most charitable interpretation I can think of for the general silence is that leaders are afraid that acknowledging such radical ideas, even to counter them, will offer them legitimacy. But some may believe that it’s in their interest to play footsie with this movement to woo more alienated young men to the Republican camp.

That is a serious moral and strategic error. …

This is about tribal thinking, of course, but it’s also a basic example of fascism: the idea that certain people are better than others and deserve to rule. Yes, there are basic biological differences between men and women… but they’re not about how to run a global society. Evidence suggests countries run by women are… healthier, than otherwise. And global society is inevitable.

Posted in Human Nature, Morality, Politics | Leave a comment

Is the Purpose of Living Is to be Useful?

More about meaning and mattering. (I’ll get to that Rebecca Newberger Goldstein book real soon now.) I’m not feeling morbid, or moribund, I’m just curious to see what kind of things people are looking for.

NY Times, Roger Rosenblatt, guest opinion essay, today: Thoughts Near the End of a Life

He’s a writer.

Here, in the still-dark mornings on the East River, the first thing I see from my apartment window is a tugboat, dressed in white and yellow lights, prepared to tow and push the tonnage of garbage from a sanitation plant. Patient, stoic little dockworker. I often think it waits for me, as if it were captained by Charon at the entrance to the River Styx.

I follow the tides and welts as the river flows uptown, past New York’s big-city mixture of rich apartments and tenements, schools, hospitals, past the treacherous channel of Hell Gate near Randall’s and Wards Islands, out to realize its true estuary identity, where it disappears. Unseen by me, the river becomes Long Island Sound, then the Atlantic. It grows from the small known to the magnificent invisible.

Have I made a ripple with my life? The question every old person asks. Family, yes. Wife, children, grandchildren. Friends, yes. Work? As a writer, who knows? You send things out to an unseen public, like paper boats on water. Do you change a mind, a heart? Abdul El-Sayed, the senator-elect from Michigan, says that his religion teaches that saving one life is like saving all of humanity. The same thought is in the Talmud. That’s the writer’s creed as well.

His answer. And he talks about writing an essay about Lewis Thomas.

To have been of use to others. That would constitute more than a ripple. In the 1990s I was writing an essay for The Times on Lewis Thomas, the great physician-philosopher and the author of “The Lives of a Cell” and other books connecting science, the arts and life. Lewis, a friend, was dying, and I wanted to ask him about that. He said he’d prefer to talk about living. He said he thought the purpose of living was to be useful. Me, too.

(I noted that Lewis Thomas book here, and did a more thorough review of his later book, LATE NIGHT THOUGHTS ON LISTENING TO MAHLER’S NINTH SYMPHONY, here.)

A bit more.

When my wife, Ginny, and I were expecting our first child, Carl, I wrote my university mentor and friend John Kelleher about how excited I was. Would I be a good father? Would our son be given all he would need to prepare him for the future? John wrote back, “I’m going to tell you what my father told me when I wrote him a note as dreamily romantic as yours: You take what you get, and you do what you can with it.”

I tried.

And life does what it can with you, teaches you, as becoming more empathic proves. Things change. You change. Life is new, at once old and new. Above the river, terns swoop and squawk, looking down on all we do here, beginnings and ends. Old man’s river. Old man’s life.

I’m left with trying to be useful, and in very modest ways, I think I am.

\\\

Two more of those AI intellectual sites.

Philosophy of Physics

The Hidden Layer

Update to earlier posts about Oddly Human. It seems the group has changed to a subscription group, so the videos are accessible only to subscribers.

At the same time, there’s a YouTube channel, which I’ve discovered but haven’t checked out yet.

\\

Ongoing story.

There’s no connection to AI, apparently, but of course the current administration blames the previous administration.

CNN, today: What we know about the cause of the nationwide FAA ground stop

There are lots of stories about this, and lots of perspectives. But even if you take the current administration at its word, why didn’t they *notice* problems with FAA? In the past two years? And instead spend money on ballrooms and arches?

\\\

Brief links.

Posted in Meaning, Politics, Religion | Leave a comment

Maps and Territories

  • The latest ‘map’ of the universe from the latest space telescope;
  • Big Think profiles a book by Steven Strogatz and Alex Townsend about “big math,” and how to understand and influence it;
  • Kevin Kelly on AI as “new units of knowledge” and standardization;
  • And today’s rumors that the FAA shutdown of flights was due to AI: maybe, maybe not.
– – –

The maps have gotten so big they’re barely comprehensible, let alone the territories they correspond to.

Scientific American, Mary Randolph, today: See the first glimpses of the most ambitious map of the universe yet, subtitled “The images are part of Euclid’s first major data release”

Euclid being the European Space Agency’s (ESA) newest space telescope.

“These are far more than beautiful pictures; today marks a scientific milestone in our study of the cosmos,” said Carole Mundell, the agency’s director of science, in a statement. “This major Euclid data release represents the largest space-based survey of its kind, laying the foundation of future discovery in a new regime for astronomy and demonstrating the excellence of European technology, science and international collaboration.”

Such as?

This mosaic forms the basis of what could one day be a full cosmic map. It spans nearly 500 gigapixels in size—equivalent to at least 10,000 high-quality smartphone images. It’s made up of 740 observations and includes more than 900 million galaxies.

Of course, humans can’t begin to have any intuitive idea of what these distances and sizes mean. The lessons from scientific discoveries should humble people. (Yet they don’t.)

\\\

Similarly: we live in a world increasingly beyond the comprehension of most of its residents.

Big Think, Ross Pomeroy, 12 Nov 2026: We built our world on “Big Math.” Now we no longer understand it., subtitled “Mathematicians Steven Strogatz and Alex Townsend explain how ‘Big Math’ came to rule our lives and how we can reclaim control.”

This concerns a book called Big Math: The Hidden Codes That Run Our World, by Steven Strogatz and Alex Townsend. (I would submit that most people everywhere have never understood any kind of math.)

And it concerns the very recent advances in AI.

Clearly, their book’s publication was impeccably timed for the moment, and Strogatz and Townsend have since been publicly grappling with the potential ramifications for their field. Notably, in an article in The New York Times, they fretted that using AI as a solution factory for math problems deprives humans of the insights that arise when mathematicians struggle through mind-boggling problems.

With some perspective.

Townsend and Strogatz are also lamenting the potential loss of a less well-known aspect of mathematics. Contrary to the stereotypes, it’s a remarkably social discipline.

“You see in the media that there are all these lonely people that spend ten years on a problem. This is not the reality of most mathematicians,” Townsend said. “Most math is a collaborative, social activity. It’s a rare few that do their own thing in their office. Most papers have many co-authors with many people collaborating and coming up with ideas. We’d like to keep that in the future.”

What can the ordinary person do? Mathematical literacy.

He noted that Big Math fundamentally underpins more controversial technologies: data centers, surveillance systems, cyberweapons, drones, and military targeting systems. The public, not just technocrats, CEOs, and venture capitalists, must shape regulation of these technologies. Mathematical literacy can help people feel empowered to join the conversation and decisions we need to make, Strogatz said.

Such literacy doesn’t mean excelling at geometry and matrix/matrix multiplication; it means having a basic understanding of Big Math’s reach and effects. Then anyone can take action.

Ask questions: What’s being optimized? Are there feedback loops? What’s missing? Is it interpretable? How uncertain is it?

“Every mathematical invention begins and ends with human choices,” Townsend and Strogatz write. “We might never fully understand the oracles we’ve made, but we can decide what to ask of them, and why. We can remain the conscience behind the code.”

\\\

A perspective from Kevin Kelly.

Kevin Kelly, 9 Nov 2026: New Units of Knowledge

We each have a magic genie that will do whatever we ask of it. So do we still need anything from other people? By the same logic, if everyone else has a magic genie that does whatever they want, why would anyone need something we make?

Another way of saying that is: if the magic genie makes creation abundant, what will become scarce and valuable?

Of course the magic genie is AI. The question of the hour is: if AI serves as a magical personal assistant, or a general partner, for any chore we choose, what happens to our old economic relationships?

Things are changing, or about to change, in ways we cannot anticipate. At the same time, as William Gibson observed, the future is here, it’s just not evenly distributed. Plenty of people will go on with their daily lives completely unaware of how AI is infiltrating daily existence, and influencing the decisions they think they alone are making.

He goes on, with how standardization [[ regulations! ]] make exchanges of ideas possible.

Standardization does not preclude difference and variety, which will become the precious scarcities. Standardization is what makes difference valuable. The standard 26 letters of the alphabet, and our standard dictionary of words, enable the value of weird arrangements of letters and words to be captured by anyone. Just as we humans can produce endless abundant strings of words, but only a few distinct ones are worth paying attention to, our magic genies will endlessly produce movies, software programs, simulations, entire worlds, and we all (agents too) will gravitate to those that are distinctive in some manner.

Which brings us back to the first question. We will still need other people in so far as they can lean into their particular life experiences, and together with their personal genie, generate distinctive magic.

The new artifacts of knowledge will succeed if they can carry those distinctions in a standardized way, the way 26 identical letters, the same for everyone, carry every distinct thing ever written.

\\\

Current events. Flights were grounded yesterday. Today, rumors flied on Facebook. Here’s an example.

And of course, the current administration *has* blamed the previous administration — especially Biden and Buttigieg — for the failure, despite this administration’s having cut hundreds of jobs from the FAA, and being in charge of the government for two years now.

But correlation is not causation, and we shouldn’t jump to conclusions. (Despite my predilection to blame the incompetence of the current administration for everything. It’s always a safe bet.)

The Atlantic, Juliette Kayyem, yesterday: Of Course Americans Blamed the Ground Stop on AI, subtitled “When anything can go wrong, speculation flourishes.”

For many hours, the Federal Aviation Administration did not explain why it issued a national ground stop in the United States this afternoon. The agency described the cause only as a “telecommunications outage” and cited “extraordinary circumstances,” but failed to say more. So speculation abounded: Was the problem connected with the onboarding of a new AI route-selection system this week? Is it somehow related to the Microsoft Outlook outage this week? Or is the cause some antiquated telecommunications system that just finally gave up trying?

Because human psychology jumps to conclusions, even though they might be wrong. Snake in the grass. Better safe than sorry. Being wrong, in most cases, doesn’t matter.

In the absence of solid information from trusted authorities, people interpret crises through the prism of their preexisting concerns. When the aviation system shut down, many Americans’ minds went to DOGE cuts, cyberattacks by hostile foreign actors, recent reports of renegade AI. A safety planner’s job is to envision the full range of possible threats and assess how likely each one is to occur. Even before recent advances in artificial intelligence, the list of factors that could jeopardize commercial aviation was already long: terrorism, extreme weather, staffing strains, the decay of outdated communications networks, and more. AI could theoretically help the aviation system manage risks and disruptions, but it also adds many more variables that could go wrong.

Yet it may take a while for everything to become known.

\\

Listening to the soundtrack of Fargo, by Carter Burwell. Can’t find a clean video on YouTube.

Let’s try this one. The music is ominous, and foreboding, in an intriguing way. But it’s only the opening movement… no, it advances to subsequent tracks.

Posted in Cosmology, Mathematics, Music, Politics, Technology | Leave a comment

Dilutions, Pollutions, Evolutions

I’m sitting down to read this interview with Emily St. John Mandel, author of STATION ELEVEN, this year’s EXIT PARTY, and from a few years ago SEA OF TRANQUILITY, which I was distinctly unimpressed by (see this post). Since then, just a few months ago, I read STATION ELEVEN, which I liked better, though its SF elements were no less superficial.

Vox, Byrd Pinkerton and Joanna Solotaroff, yesterday 12 Nov 2026: How science informs author Emily St. John Mandel’s fiction, subtitled “The author of Station Eleven talks science, fiction, and doppelgängers.”

The new book concerns the multiverse. “We talked about how she approaches science in her fiction, and how, even if we never get clear answers to some of these strange ideas, they can still help us think deeply about ourselves and our world.”

Emily, you are often writing about really interesting scientific ideas. Why do you put these scientific concepts at the heart of the books that you write?

Because they’re so interesting. I don’t have an educational background in science. I didn’t study it in school. I did work in a cancer research lab for years, so I’ve definitely hung out with scientists. I was great with grant budgets. But I could not actually tell you the mechanisms by which microRNA 335 impacts breast cancer metastasis.

… But you know what? Science is interesting to me. I like reading about ideas in the fringes of science. But my understanding is that physicists are more or less evenly split on the question of whether we’re living in a multiverse.

Later, we see she is aware of at least one other science fiction writer.

When you’re borrowing these scientific concepts, do you feel trapped by the science of it all? Do you feel like you have to stay within certain boundaries?

I don’t, which may annoy some readers of sci-fi, but I think there’s a really interesting choice that you have to make if you’re writing speculative fiction, and that’s how accurate do you want to be, or how deep into the weeds do you want to go with your science fictional technology?

On one end of the spectrum, you’ve got an author like Cixin Liu, who wrote The Three-Body Problem. I really love his work. He gets so granular about those technologies. …

Alas, I was similarly unimpressed by Cixin Liu, as I wrote about here over a decade ago.

It can be revelatory when someone takes a fresh perspective on a familiar theme — someone whose mind hasn’t been molded by ‘conventional wisdom’ about, for instance, how time travel works. She says:

I’ve always loved time travel novels as a reader and a fan. The problem with the time travel narrative, though, is that it falls apart instantly.

If you think about it for a second, it’s like, if I walk out of this podcast studio and I’m transported back to 1812, was I not always going to walk out of the studio and be transported back to 1812? And doesn’t reality break upon my arrival?

But this is just naivete. She thinks no one has thought about these things before.

She’s not original; rather her books are examples of how common sf tropes have been absorbed by conventional fiction as devices without any real thought being applied. Such books are only superficially science fiction. (And they’re the complete opposite of books by someone like M. John Harrison.)

\\\

Here’s another item that, in a sense, is about how science fiction is misunderstood by the mundanes.

Paul Krugman, 10 Nov 2026: The Cyberpunking of America (Fixed), subtitled “How the tech broligarchs tried to inflict their dystopian dreams on the rest of us”

(The word “fixed” refers to a previous attempt by Krugman to post the piece.)

This is about the imminent demise of Elon Musk’s cybertruck.

A few years ago my wife and I were driving in New Jersey, when she suddenly exclaimed, “What’s that incredibly ugly car?” It was her first sighting of a Cybertruck in the wild.

Now Tesla is finally pulling the plug on the vehicle, which one person quoted in a New York Times report describes as looking like a mechanical cockroach — an image one can’t unsee.

So what’s the big deal? Businesses make bum investments all the time. It’s true that the Cybertruck’s failure was spectacular — Dave Phillips, the author of the piece, who was clearly having fun, pointed out that it’s unfair to compare the Cybertruck to the Edsel, which had much bigger sales.

Put in cultural context:

The 7-year arc of the Cybertruck coincided with the transformation of Musk’s public image from that of a planet-friendly innovator to that of a racist, conspiracy-theorizing, African-children-killing oligarch. Once upon a time driving a Tesla was a way to signal that you were rich but environmentally conscious. But driving a Cybertruck became a signal of MAGA fealty.

Yet there is an even wider cultural context here. The Cybertruck was the physical embodiment of a dystopian ideology that has become dominant among billionaire tech bros — an ideology that draws heavily from cyberpunk novels and movies.

Earlier tech bros worshiped Ayn Rand. Now it’s William Gibson and Blade Runner. They miss the point:

But rather than taking cyberpunk’s visions of dystopia as cautionary tales, they saw them as manifestos. And with the great power that flows from great wealth, they have been trying to turn their adolescent dreams into reality.

The cybertruck; Mark Zuckerberg’s “metaverse.” Oligarchs’ dreams:

Crucially, while you or I might read Neuromancer or watch Blade Runner and shudder at their visions of the future, billionaire tech bros surely picture themselves living in that future not as unemployed and homeless, but as edgelords ruling the world. Technological dystopia may sound like a nightmare to most of us, but for the broligarchs — despite their occasional expressions of concern and mumbling about Universal Basic Income — it’s basically a dream, which they are trying to use their financial and political power to make come true.

But the public isn’t buying it — literally in the case of Cybertrucks and the Metaverse, figuratively in the form of overwhelming voter opposition to data centers and AI in general.

But both of this pieces are examples of how science fiction, in the context of popular and fine culture, has evolved. A hundred years ago, it was crudely written pulp magazine stories.

\\\

Briefly.

Posted in Evolution, Politics, science fiction | Leave a comment

But Of Course AI Cannot Be Trusted

  • More about interesting websites that look AI-generated;
  • And how Jesse Bering just noted one such on Facebook;
  • Comments about M. John Harrison’s THE END OF EVERYTHING.
– – –

First of all, the link to the video I embedded yesterday from a Facebook Group called Oddly Human, about human evolution and psychopathy, now leads only to a post on the group’s page, not a video, which I now can’t find. Hmm.

Meanwhile, today, I came across five similar groups, that like Oddly Human, post several times a day video essays about various intellectual topics. Most of them indicate AI content; one or two indicate a specific city location, and even a contact phone number.

Primitive Mind
Transcendental Space
The Untold
The Shadow Mind
Theory of Everything

I don’t spend lots of time on Facebook, actually. I check it several times a day, for three or four minutes at a time. Of course, because I “followed” Oddly Human yesterday means that Fb is showing me more similar posts.

Continue reading →

Posted in science fiction, Technology | Leave a comment

Another Side of AI?

  • An insightful Facebook group called Oddly Human seems AI driven;
  • At the opposite extreme are people who are “not even wrong,” as this person who wonders why gravity was even invented;
  • Christian Nationalists are not changing their plans; and Christian antipathy toward empathy goes way back, remembering “bleeding heart liberals.”
– – –

More and more content, everywhere, seems AI-driven. Is this an example? I’m not sure.

Facebook, Oddly Human, 9 Nov 2026:

Here’s a fascinating video, some 15 minutes long, that explores psychopathy and human evolution. Why didn’t evolution weed out psychopaths, who are so damaging to social stability? A simplex question that has a complex answer.

The answer is there are trade-offs between traits in human nature that are beneficial or detrimental to varying degrees in society, but which still contribute to genetic survival to varying degrees to the individual. Similar arguments could be made about autism (which this group posted about today) and homosexuality. I find this piece compelling and succinct.

But who is/are Oddly Human? Continue reading →

Posted in Evolution, Human Nature | Leave a comment

The Ability to Change

Is the ability to survive.

  • Adam Frank thinks politics can learn from science about knowing when to change your mind;
  • While Jesse Bering explains how we tend to rewrite data to fit our worldview;
  • Cases in point: Stephen Miller doubles down; Trump resorts to accusations of election fraud;
  • While Ocasio-Cortez admits to having evolved;
  • And a Facebook graphic from someone who thinks the Fibonacci sequence is evidence of an intelligent designer (it’s not).
– – –

Several items today align along a common theme, one that relates to science, and politics, and religion, and human psychology. And science fiction.

Adam Frank, Everyman’s Universe, 6 Nov 2026: What Can Politics Learn From Science?, subtitled “The art of changing your mind.”

The answer is the subtitle.

Continue reading →

Posted in conservatives, Mathematics, Psychology, Religion | Leave a comment

Classics and Shifting Cultural Values

  • Are the classics always conservative?
  • With my thoughts on what constitutes classics, at least in music;
  • NYT speculates on a winning political agenda;
  • A personal aside about the shifts in political parties;
  • What the Elizabeth Holmes movie says about American gullibility;
  • How prayer doesn’t work, yet again.
– – –

What would a solid, basic, nonpartisan, ecumenical education consist of? I outlined some ideas five years ago here. But what about culture? Music, literature?

Slate, Rebecca Onion, today: I Want My Daughter to Love Reading and Writing. How Far Would I Go to Get Her There?, subtitled “Christian conservatives are leading the charge on a type of education that, in the right light, looks pretty appealing.”

My first thought is that, of course, conservatives value the classics. Why is that surprising?

Onion assess the current state of things. Then,
Continue reading →

Posted in Culture, Morality, Music, Religion | Leave a comment

Our Ultraprocessed World

  • An essay about how modern manufacturers exploit evolutionary impulses, from Doritos to AI;
  • NYT’s ideas to fix America;
  • How Trump confused two different Dana Whites;
  • Shostakovich’s 10th.
– – –

Understanding modern society through evolution.

NY Times, guest essay by Angela Duckworth, posted 5 Nov 2026, in today’s print paper: These Inventions Were Built to Trick Us

Print title: “Our World Has Become Ultraprocessed.”

Much of this is well-known. The insight here is how AI is just another manifestation of this trend.

It begins with an anecdote about tricking oystercatcher birds into sitting on larger and larger eggs — even fake ones.

Continue reading →

Posted in Evolution, Music, Social Progress | Comments Off on Our Ultraprocessed World

Richard Haass, THE BILL OF OBLIGATIONS

Subtitled “The Ten Habits of Good Citizens”
(Penguin Press, January 2023, xix + 217pp, including 42pp of acknowledgements, “Where To Go For More,” notes, and index)

Not familiar with this author, who is president of the nonpartisan Council on Foreign Relations. I was fascinated by this book because first, it’s a counterpart to all those alternate ten commandments lists, and second, it flips the idea of civil ‘rights,’ wherein the government is obliged to protect certain beliefs and behaviors of individuals, to consider instead ‘obligations,’ wherein individuals are expected to display certain behaviors toward their fellow citizens. His list is a good one, though I wondered just what he meant by the tenth, “Put Country First.” Over what? We’ll find out.

Key Points

  • He begins by examining the failures of our rights-based democracy: complex problems are not best decided by popular vote, and too many people lack expertise to vote intelligently. And the Constitution was a compromise on some key issues.
  • Comparing 1968 to Jan 6th, for example, things are getting worse. Our system was set up when the population was comparatively tiny; now we suffer a tyranny of the minority. Institutions are being weakened. Social media has no quality control.
  • Obligation #1: Be informed. Understand how things work. Understand what facts are.
  • #2: Get involved. Vote, and do more if you can.
  • #3: Stay open to compromise. Don’t hold out for perfection; beware criticism from extremists.
  • #4: Remain civil. Argue issues, don’t make things personal.
  • #5: Reject violence. Using crime for political purposes is terrorism.
  • #6: Value norms. These are the unwritten traditions, rules, customs, etc., that reduce friction in society. Like looking out for neighbors, and accepting election results.
  • #7: Promote the common good. We all have a stake in the well-being of our fellow citizens.
  • #8: Respect government service. People make mistakes, but there are mechanisms for detecting and correcting them. Public service might be incentivized, but not required.
  • #9: Support the teaching of civics. The basics of American society and economy. Immigrants often know these better than natives.
  • #10: Put country first. Over party and person. Unlike examples from Republicans and MAGA.
  • Conclusion: Obligations, along with rights, are at the core of the idea of citizenship. Think institutionally: leave one in better shape than how you found it. We can’t count on virtue winning out.

Continue reading →

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Politics, Social Progress | Comments Off on Richard Haass, THE BILL OF OBLIGATIONS